 |
|
|
|
|
|
 |
| ||||||||
 |
 
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| ||||||||
|
|
| 
| User list | You are not logged in.
Pages: 1
Hello:
I have been trying for hours to stitch these 2 pictures, Autopano does not find matching points and its really fustrating. I have tryed reading through this forum but I have had no luck.
In essence I was hoping that someone would teach me how to get this done so that any future pics I can fix myself.
Here are the pics...
I have uploaded pics to photobucket for anyone that would like to help me complete this challenge 
http://i407.photobucket.com/albums/pp15 … 010305.jpg
http://i407.photobucket.com/albums/pp15 … 010303.jpg
Regards,
Estefano
Offline
Estefano,
The problem is that your pictures have barely any overlap.
To get a good stitch you need 25%-30% overlap between the pictures.
Offline
Mediavets:
Thanks, are these pics no good or is there anything I can do to try to stitch them?
Regards,
Estefano
Offline
eisaiasjr wrote:
Mediavets:
Thanks, are these pics no good or is there anything I can do to try to stitch them?
Regards,
Estefano
They´re no spherical shots - therefore and due to the rare overlap no stitcher will do it.
But it should be no problem to combine them in Photoshop - though they need heavy perspective correction.
best, Klaus
Last edited by klausesser (2008-12-02 23:41:20)
Offline
Just a quick try.....
Offline
Number-88:
Was this stitch done with photoshop?
Regards,
Estefano
Offline
Hi Estefano,
No, 
I have tryed with the laptop of a friend of mine with APP (older 1.3 version). Unfortunally as others before correct stated, there is to little overlap for a good/resonable stitch.
The picture is made with PTGUI... (sorry AlexandreJ )
Its not 100% but this is done quickly. If you would take some time you could get somewhat more quality, but again there is very very little overlap.
Greetings.
Rick
Last edited by number-88 (2008-12-03 08:08:39)
Offline
Done with APP 1.4.2. But how?
Offline
By using the control point editor, you can achieve a good result quickly :
http://www.autopano.net/wiki/action/vie … _panoramas
Offline
I tried with the CP editor, but APP 1.4.2/linux can't find control points, even with high level detection, advanced distorsion and so. Strange...
Offline
fma38 wrote:
I tried with the CP editor, but APP 1.4.2/linux can't find control points, even with high level detection, advanced distorsion and so. Strange...
My experience was the same - APP 1.4.2/WinXP - I think Alexandre must be using an alpha release of V2?
Offline
In the CP Editor I had to set both strong algorithm and high detector quality. Drawing the marquees, I included all the overlap - the island in the background on its own doesn't work, for me.
Also, doing a detection then removing the detected points then doing the detection again one gets a differing result - all the parameters remaining the same. See screenshots. Note: both these are before/without optimisation. You can see there are falsely detected points e.g. 11 and 23 in second example
Offline
Hum, not easy with the downgraded version available on the first topic.
Offline
leedsjoe wrote:
In the CP Editor I had to set both strong algorithm and high detector quality. Drawing the marquees, I included all the overlap - the island in the background on its own doesn't work, for me.
Also, doing a detection then removing the detected points then doing the detection again one gets a differing result - all the parameters remaining the same. See screenshots. Note: both these are before/without optimisation. You can see there are falsely detected points e.g. 11 and 23 in second example
there are also falsely detected points in the first one (e.g. 9). And there are a few points on waves and the sky. The points on the wood don't look so good either.
I tried it and got the same sort of results leedsjoe did -- CPs detected but not correct.
If you zoom in on the island and the smokestack (or whatever it is) you can see a building with windows. I could set manual CPs on them and get some sort of result--well, I could set manual CPs if APP let me set manual CPs.
This sort of error has been discussed before, and IIRC Alexandre was talking about adding another detection scheme to the CP editor for this error.
Offline
hankkarl wrote:
This sort of error has been discussed before, and IIRC Alexandre was talking about adding another detection scheme to the CP editor for this error.
I confirm this one. Starting february, we'll have a person here dedicated to this only task during 5 months.
Offline
Alexandre,
Thanks for the point in your last post. Very interesting problem highlights need for additionally functionality!
Offline
BTW : a fully manual control point editor is also planned for v2. This will be done probably mid-december.
Offline
mid December 2008.....right??
Do we see the next alpha version by then?
Offline
We probably won't, as this is just 10 days away and manual CP editing is (was?) not planned for the next alpha...
Offline
Has this feature made it in the final version? I can't seem to find it but still miss it a lot. Couldn't find anything via the forum search, too...
If it's in, where should I look for it?
Tipjip
Offline
Couldn't make it for final. After we have done the documentation, we just have 2 features with really high priority : HDR and manual control point editor. Anything else will be postponed.
Offline
Good to know it hasn't been canceled. Thanks for the info!
Tipjip
Offline
I hope this solve my problem (http://www.autopano.net/forum/viewtopic … 271#p47271). I am waiting for this update.
Offline
Pages: 1
